For the last five years in Russia, the Renault Logan car has taken the place of the leader. But in 16, or rather in 15, he had a competitor, Lada Vesta. Let's determine which is better. Which car is still in the lead? Vesta strives to give the driver comfort and variety of equipment no worse than Logan, and in some places it even wins. In comparison, you can immediately see some factors that are in the lead. Vesta is a budget car, Logan is also a budget car, which means it is the most popular - so the battle is for every buyer. Among budget employees, Renault Logan has a high sales rating, or even a leader in its class. It has been on sale for about 10 years and has found its niche and has its own buyer. Lada Vesta was released in 2015; its popularity soared, if you look at sales, and Logan has been selling steadily for a long time and the model was restyled Renault Logan 2 - which time will tell. We were able to compare these cars - read the comparison and make your choice.
AvtoVAZ promised that Vesta would be beautiful in appearance, more powerful, and practical in practice. During assembly, high-quality materials were used, at a relatively low price - the golden mean for a budget employee. Logan, in turn, is affordable for average Russians, it is reliable, unpretentious, and the price is not off the charts; it deserves special mention; it is a fairly strong car. Version Logan 2, well suited for harsh climates, is definitely a car for Russia. The updated version of Logan proved to be a picky car with cheap spare parts.
Vehicle platforms
These two cars are leaders in their class, but Vesta still outperforms Logan on the platform. Due to its dimensions, the Lada Vesta belongs to the B plus platform and, indeed, in many respects, it is several centimeters larger than its competitors. Logan belongs to category B and is less than Vesta.
A platform was specially developed for the Lada Vesta. The car is perfectly tuned to the climatic conditions of Russia. Well, the restyled Logan 2, unlike the first generation, is equipped with new parts and settings - it has been completely reconfigured.
↑ Prestige and body
To determine what superiority the Lada Vesta has among cars that represent the B class, you can compare it with the French Logan 2. It is the one that is more suitable in terms of technical characteristics and price. Renault Fluence or Captur models, the cost of which is much higher, are not taken into account.
Let's compare the second Logan and Vesta in terms of car prestige. Our Lada definitely has the advantage. The modern Lada model is unrecognizably different from previous AvtoVAZ representatives. The design and technical parameters of Vesta play a significant role in trying to compete for a prize among foreign cars.
Of course, the second Logan is far ahead of the first version in terms of external design. The restyling turned out to be excellent: new headlights, grille, quality material on the front and rear seats. After its release, Logan 2 received a huge number of reviews, both positive and negative. But still I liked the model.
The Lada Vesta produced an even greater effect. After her first presentation, reviews poured in on the Internet. The car made a strong impression on car enthusiasts. The body has undergone changes; it has greater length, width and ground clearance than its competitor. The only thing is that Logan’s trunk volume is 30 liters more.
Body and design
Naturally, you shouldn’t compare Vesta with the first version of Logan. It was a square design 10 years ago. After restyling, Renault was completely transformed, all the qualities it inherited from the first model have not disappeared anywhere, it is still durable and unpretentious. However, its design is more strict, although everything combines well, but Vesta also does not suffer from poor form. When developing Logan, the designers did not rely on design; most likely, it was designed for simple forms - using the machine for work.
Vesta stands out because its design lines are thoughtful and also elegant. Logan beats the Vesta by only 2 centimeters in body height. In terms of length/width, 2180 wins: 4410 versus 4345 millimeters.
To sum up the design, let's say: due to its simplicity, Logan loses to the news.
Vesta appearance vs Renault Logan 2 exterior
Comparison of Lada Vesta and Renault Logan 2 The French competitor looks decent, which makes it even more popular among ordinary fans.
Lada Vesta was created with the intention of eradicating from the minds of buyers the idea that a car from Russia cannot look fashionable and attractive - and when looking at it, such an impression is created (even on video). AvtoVAZ engineers have a firm intention to expand the range of body styles, releasing a hatchback and a station wagon in the near future. At the moment, competitors creating Renault Logan 2 do not have an advantage in this aspect.
- The new product from AvtoVAZ immediately established itself as a car with a stylish design. Many called it the discovery of the year. Vesta's body is decorated with X-shaped stampings. The front part of the Russian car harmoniously combines a chrome radiator grille, headlights and front bumper, which gives great shine to the appearance. Having colorful dimensions, Lada Vesta looks very solid.
- Renault Logan 2 has a simple design. External features are straightforward and perceived unemotionally. The headlights, which are small in size, are located at an angle and harmoniously fit into the radiator grille. The car elegantly combines all body elements (front, rear and side). They note that the outlines of cheapness are visible in the external image. The Renault Logan 2 profile does not have any stampings or other fragments that emphasize its uniqueness.
Lada Vesta, due to its novelty and aggressive dynamics, wins in the category of exterior and prestige. The car is endowed with an extraordinary appearance and is etched in the memory of potential buyers for a long time. Renault designers did not bet on what Logan 2 would look like. The car makes you notice other qualities and compare it with a car of a more attractive design.
Engines and resource
The French car entered the market with only two engines. Vesta has two Russian-developed engines, one of them is 1.6 liters and the other is 1.8 liters. In terms of power characteristics, Vesta is also ahead. Engine 106,122 horsepower, versus 82, 102 Loganovsky. The basic version 2180 is equipped with a 106 horsepower engine and the top version with 122 horsepower. At this point we give a plus to Lada Vesta.
Renault is the leader in the resource, Logan engines travel about 400 thousand km without major repairs.
On Vesta, if the timing belt breaks, it bends the valves and the engine dies. Engines 2180 run differently because there are 2 of them. Engine 21129, thanks to its simple design, can be looked after without major repairs for 250,000 km - it will go even more if you take care of it.
If we talk about the service life, it depends on the owner of the car; there was one example that traveled 400,000 km without major repairs. There were some that went 50,000 and then needed major repairs, so it all depends on the driver.
Specifications
In this regard, a full comparison is not yet possible, since sales of the Lada Vesta began quite recently and now you can only buy a car with a 106-horsepower engine. Regarding the remaining engines, technical data on them is available, but some nuances regarding operational characteristics are unclear.
Video: CHOOSE: LADA VESTA OR RENAULT LOGAN
In terms of technical characteristics, the Lada Vesta is ahead of its rival in everything - its engine range is wider (3 engines versus 2), and the units themselves are more powerful. The choice of transmissions is also wider. Both cars are equipped only with gasoline, naturally aspirated engines with a volume of 1.6 liters, in-line cylinder layout, distributed fuel injection (injector) and transverse arrangement.
The first power unit of Renault Logan is an 82-horsepower 8-valve. Its output is small and amounts to only 82 horses at 5,000 rpm, but this is partly compensated by the torque of 134 Nm at 2,800 rpm. Its dynamics are mediocre, as is its maximum speed – 11.9 seconds. up to hundreds and 179 km/h, respectively. But the consumption is unpleasantly impressive - in the city it reaches 9.8 liters.
The more powerful brother already has 16 valves, thanks to which its output increases to 102 horses, but the peak speed is shifted even further up - by 5,750 rpm. The thrust also increased slightly (up to 145 “newtons”), as well as its peak speed – 3,750 rpm. The dynamic characteristics of this modification are noticeably better and it reaches hundreds in 10.5 seconds, with a maximum speed of 180 km. Consumption, of course, is not the smallest - 9.4 l (city).
Vesta can oppose the first Renault Logan engine with a domestically produced 8-valve engine of similar design (series 21116). Its power is slightly greater and amounts to 87 horses, which is available at 5,100 rpm, with 140 Nm of torque at 3,800 rpm. The dynamics will be approximately equal to Granta with the same engine - about 12.2 seconds. up to 100 km/h, with a maximum speed of 167 km/h and a consumption of 9 liters.
Nowadays Lada Vesta is sold with a 106-horsepower 16-valve version 21127, all the power of which is achieved at 5,800 rpm, with 148 Nm of thrust at 4,800 rpm. Despite similar characteristics, Vesta loses to the French sedan in dynamics - 11.8 seconds. versus 10.5 sec. up to one hundred square meters, which is partly due to the weight, since the Russian model is 100 kg heavier. Max speed is 178 km/h, with an appetite of 9.3 liters.
The top-end HR16DE-H4M engine from Alliance Renault Nissan has been derated to 114 horsepower (from the original 117 hp). Peak power is achievable at 6,000 rpm, and 158 Nm of thrust is available at 4,000 rpm. In terms of dynamics, it is in no way inferior to the Renault Logan engine, reaching 100 km/h in 10.4 seconds, with a top speed of 192 km/h. But its consumption is significantly lower and only slightly exceeds 8 liters when driving around the city.
In addition, there is information about the development of a 1.8-liter domestic engine, intended primarily for the X-Ray model. However, it will not be installed on Vesta before September 2021, and its characteristics are still classified.
Equipment and cost
The Vesta's configuration is superior to that of the Logan; it is equipped with four trim levels. The basic configuration of Logan is empty. You need to take it if you are really short on money. This configuration costs 419,000 rubles. Not enough for 2021.
Yes, this equipment is cheaper than the Lada Vesta in the base, this is due to the 8 valve engine. Top-end equipment, even higher than that of the Vesta. The price for Lada vesta ranges from 514,000 thousand to 633,000 rubles.
The basic logan we talked about starts at 419,000 and ends at 719,990 rubles. The Lada Vesta in the database is richer in configuration. In the base, the Lada has a lifting assistance system, abs, ebd, esc. The steering wheel is adjustable for reach and tilt. There is an electric power steering, Glonass era. a car of this configuration costs 490,000 rubles. A similar Frenchman will cost 540,000 rubles.
How much do the models cost?
The basic configuration of the Lada Vesta costs 465,000. To buy a French car, you need to pay 450 thousand rubles. A comparison of Lada Vesta and Renault Logan 2 shows that the luxury modification of a foreign car costs 20,000 rubles. more.
As a result, we can judge that the Russian development wins in many respects, from exquisite design to more powerful hardware. Some may prefer Renault Logan 2 for its simplicity and reliability. In addition, this car wins in terms of fuel consumption. What to choose: Lada Vesta or Renault Logan 2 is a matter of individual preference and relative liking for the product.
Battle of the salons
It’s not easy to determine which salon is better, so let’s start with the technical characteristics right away. Despite the fact that the vesta is wider than the reno, its interior is higher, which means there is more headroom - more comfortable for larger people.
VAZ engineers did a good job on the car’s seats; they are adjustable over a wide range and are much more comfortable than those of a competing car.
Despite the fact that the Reno Logan's interior is higher in height, the rear passengers feel cramped. The interior of the Lada Vesta looks more solid, all the instruments are harmoniously arranged, everything is at hand. The car trim is approximately at the same level. As a result, the Russian car offers the driver and passengers more space than the Logan. Logan has good multimedia with fast response, but the 2180 is not far behind it. Multimedia and multi-function steering wheel are at a high level, easy to control, and have good sound. The top Vesta has a touch screen instead of a radio.
Salon
Inside, both models are decorated very professionally and tastefully. However, a slight advantage can still be given to Renault Logan. This is not a concession to the “veteran” at all; it’s just that the interior of the French car looks more attractive. This is by no means a criticism of Russian designers, they just really failed to surpass their French colleagues.
The Vesta dashboard looks quite traditional for all latest models. The only major difference is that it is installed at an angle towards the driver, but the layout of the panel elements leaves much to be desired. Logan is another matter, where the console is designed in a very strict and conservative, but at the same time very high-tech style. The steering wheel is also better on the French car.
As for the amount of free space, the interior of the Russian model is much more spacious than its opponent. In addition, the French had to sacrifice part of the interior volume for the sake of a larger trunk. But the quality of finishing is noticeably better in Logan, and this should not come as a surprise to anyone, since the French are inferior to few others in this aspect.
Trunk
Logan clearly succeeded with the luggage compartment, by 30 liters. more than 2180. The trunk volume of the French car is 510 liters, while the Russian car has 480 liters.
What segment of citizens are cars designed for?
Both cars are in the budget segment and are designed for the average buyer's wallet. People who can already afford an inexpensive new car. The average buyers of these cars are people from 30 to 45 years old.
Interior and prices
Renault Logan interior
The Lada Vesta is still prettier inside, although it cannot be said that the Renault Logan is deprived of beauty. After the change of generations, its extremely boring interior has become a thing of the past, giving way to an attractive and stylish design. The dashboard is small and neat, and the deep black color of the plastic combines surprisingly harmoniously with aluminum-look inserts and chrome trim on the dashboard. And shiny stripes around the air deflectors, the center console and in other places dilute the blackness.
The seats of the new Logan are noticeably more comfortable than those of its predecessor, which is especially noticeable by the high-quality padding and lateral support. The instrument cluster is simple and uncomplicated, but guarantees excellent readability, and the multimedia system will delight you with high-quality sound and prompt response to commands. There is enough space in the back, although it will frankly be cramped for three.
The quality of the Lada Vesta's interior is not inferior to the French one, but due to its more lively and interesting design it looks more advantageous. The impressive dashboard, with its deep wells, immediately sets the mood for drive, the multi-function steering wheel is very convenient, the dashboard floating towards the riders creates a feeling of massiveness, the seating is comfortable, and the ergonomics are in perfect order. There is plenty of space in the back, but the piled-up roof will make it difficult for tall passengers to fit comfortably. The luggage compartment of both models is worthy of respect - the Lada Vesta has 480 liters of usable volume, and the Renault Logan has 510 liters!
But Logan has a big advantage in price. Minimum cost 419,000 rub. versus RUB 514,000 - this is a big difference for the B segment. Of course, after the release of Vesta with an 87-horsepower engine, the price will be reduced, but obviously not to the level of Logan. However, Renault’s equipment is much poorer - the base does not have electronic security systems, steering wheel adjustments, amplifier only for an extra charge, etc. Prices in the top versions are 674,000 rubles. for Renault Logan and 658,000 rubles. for Lada Vesta. But this price tag is not final, since there are no Russian cars with a 114-horsepower power unit on sale yet. With it, Vesta will cost even more.
These car models are full-fledged competitors in the fight for attention. The cars are in the same price range and are distinguished by a high level of assembly and comfort. Designers and people promoting their product claim that competitors meet all new standards and appear to be the standard of reliability. Let's try to find out which is better than the Lada Vesta or Renault Logan 2 for the Russian car enthusiast and consider the characteristics of power units, transmissions, appearance and interior. It is always difficult to choose, especially if the objects have many advantages.
In the fight between the Russian new product and the French car, a huge demand for both models is born, as manufacturers diligently adjust them to the climatic and road conditions of the Russian Federation. There is an obvious need to compare the Lada Vesta and Renault Logan 2. The second boasts sufficient endurance and ease of use, the first is modern, attractive and exciting. What to buy? This question is relevant for professionals and amateurs.
Summarize
vesta is superior to its competitor in most respects and can offer a more spacious interior, an attractive appearance, and a more powerful engine in the basic version.
Logan wins in the following important parameters: lower fuel consumption, more headroom for passengers, and longer engine life.
The 2180 is better equipped - the top version is cheaper than its competitor, the engine is more powerful, although more voracious. In terms of engine life, the 2180 is inferior to the Reno, while the Vesta has a more ergonomic design.
We give our plus to the Russian car.
Renault Logan
Logan ranks third in sales in our country. According to Wikipedia, this budget subcompact car was designed specifically for emerging markets. In Russia, the first generation of the car was produced from 2005 to December 2015 at the Avtoframos plant (later Renault Russia) in Moscow, and since 2014, the second generation has been produced at the AvtoVAZ plant in Tolyatti.
At the end of 2021, after an update, Logan received the Stepway version. This version has increased ground clearance and different bumpers. Logan Stepway also has a city version with a CVT.
In our market, Logan is offered with one of three versions of the 1.6-liter engine: 82, 102 and 113 hp. Engines with power of 82 and 113 hp. equipped with a manual 5-speed gearbox, 102 hp engine. — 4-speed automatic transmission.
